From the way you are describing yourself I would say that the brown hair will be more becoming on you. That, of course, would depend on the look you want. The goth/vampire look is pale skin and black hair. That is not a look I care for but I know it is popular with a particular segment of youth. Black hair tends to make you look a bit older and more harsh. If you want a less startling look - go with the brown hair. An auburn might look good on you as well...that is basically brown with undercurrents of red. If you hate the brown or auburn, you can always go black. But if you go black first and then don't like that it will be much, much more difficult to change that. So..if you are undecided I would go brown or auburn and if that does not please you, try the black. Good Luck. I know hair color is a big decision and can make a difference in how you are perceived by people. One other suggestion - if you have a place that sells wigs near you, you can go try on wigs of different colors until you find one that you fall in love with. I did that and even took my husband.
I have black hair and find nw ive stopped using sunbeds and have returned to my pale skin I look like death but to remove it will damage it and make it straw like so I would say don't do it extremely dark because if you don't like it theres not much you can do.
If you have brown eyes perhaps not brown hair because it will just look bland with your eyes, I agree with the top person :P that black hair may look harsh so maybe a dark brown? X Or a brown that isn't like your eye colour because eyes are important :)
If by 'pale skin' you mean skin with a pinkish or blueish undertone, then you definitely want the brown, but not too dark of a brown...
I do too, and well I took a school picture one time and when I got it, my hair looked black on the picture and I thought I looked pretty good, but I have never tried it cause I love my brown hair.
I have dark blonde hair and dark brown eyes, really want to go darker but unsure if this will suit me. My hair is also really short which I loved.
By the way you describe urself...I say bla k is a no no kuz if you said pail skin you will look even pailer....you don't want that. But it would be nice if you dyed it a dif shade of brown than your eyez