Hi Stephanie Nesher! It´s a common struggle find a good mascara that doesn't irritate the eyes, so I got a few selection for you:
1- Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin Mascara
Because of the eye area is so sensitive, it´s important to look out for the ingredients of the makeup that we put in our eyes.In this case, this mascara is made of organic and natural ingredients that will not hurt your eyes.
1- The Body Shop - Super Volume Mascara Mascara
This mascara is made with moisturising Community Trade marula oil and beeswax so is very gentle and soothing for the eyes. It's available in three different colours (black, brown and blue).
3-Clinique High Impact Extreme Volume Mascara in Extreme Black
This makeup line is design for people with hypoallergenic problems. It promises mad volume as well as thickens and volumizes. If you look for a high-end product take a look at this line.
If that isn't good enough for you, I advise you to look for a mascara that doesn't have much alcohol or bad chemicals.Good luck ;)